14 thoughts on “WCW: Marianne Dashwood”

  1. I think the 2026 actress was done a disservice by the costuming and hair choices. (I’ll give them this though – I appreciated that she didn’t have a full face of glam makeup!) I think her performance was pretty good but the hair hanging in her face and slubby clothes was distracting.

  2. Charity Wakefield. For me she is more natural.

    Kate Winslet was perfect for her type of movie, where everything was more hm obvious.

  3. I agree with Austenprose, the Marianne in the 1971 version was sooooo annoying. I also found the whole series a snooze fest. The 2008 was tolerable, especially compared to the other Jane Austen adaptations that were produced that year, but it could never live up to the 1995 film. The actors in the 1995 version are above and beyond, the costumes were resplendent, and the directing, cinematography were beautiful. It helps when you have Hollywood money! I haven’t seen the 2026 version, but every time I see stills from it I don’t understand why they decided to make everything look so gloomy. I will still go to see it though.

  4. Kate the Great. Full stop. And my former college costume design professor made those fabulous bonnets for that film.

  5. Just heard someone describe the 2026 S&S as being attentive to period details and as having period-accurate hair on all of the actresses. Send help.

    Esme Creed-Miles is beautiful, but the messy ‘just-crawled-out-of-the-forest’ look is not it when it comes to Austen, in my opinion. Kate Winslet will always be Marianne.

  6. No contest for me: Kate Winslet. Charity Wakefield is a good second, but the 2008 adaptation is my second favourite after Emma Thompson’s efforts.

  7. Kate Winslet’s Marianne is the best, as we all agreed. I did love Creeds-Mile’s take, but GOD ALMIGHTY the hair… At one point it started getting almost dreadlock-ish. Sure, she IS kinda feral, which is interesting to see, but like, even feral cats groom themselves.

Feel the love

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.