I almost did my Master’s thesis on the intersection of fashion and Surrealism, so I want everyone to understand that I don’t say this lightly: It is a goddamn tragedy that Elsa Schiaparelli wasn’t included in the ensemble cast of artists in Hans Herbot’s This is Not a Murder Mystery (2025), even though her work is referenced repeatedly throughout the series. Seriously, I need a Schiap biopic or miniseries, and This is Not a Murder Mystery just makes me hunger for it even more. Like, how can you even conceive of having both Salvador Dalì and Gala Dalì in a show without their bestie and frequent collaborator, Schiap? Ugh, so frustrating. But with that one disappointment out of the way, I’m here to say that I thoroughly enjoyed This is Not a Murder Mystery, shocking lack of pink Schiaparelli notwithstanding — though I do have some questions that I’ve been unable to find answers to online, but more on that after we chat about the costumes.
I do want to state up front that there’s no real point in trying to match events and timelines in the show to the real world events in the lives of the artists, because this show is the epitome of playing fast and loose with history, and they’re honest about it in the title card before every episode:

And that’s a legit way to approach the entire Surrealist movement. Surrealism was in large part about playing on the fact that human nature wants to trust the senses, and yet those senses are often fallible and easily manipulated. A painting of a pipe is not a pipe, you know? It’s a representation of a pipe, or a simulacrum of a pipe, or even the idea of a pipe, but it isn’t an actual pipe.

“The famous pipe. How people reproached me for it! And yet, could you stuff my pipe? No, it’s just a representation, is it not? So if I had written on my picture ‘This is a pipe’, I’d have been lying!”
— René Magritte
The premise: A party at a wealthy benefactor’s rambling English estate draws together a dozen or so Surrealist artists and their companions under the auspices of creating a sensational exhibit for a select audience of the rich and well-connected. Then one of the guests is murdered, and we are thrown into a cozy murder mystery world where everyone is a suspect and, of course, more murders happen to whittle the party down and amp up the paranoia of the survivors. The vibe is a lot colder than a typical cozy murder mystery, no doubt due to the fact that it’s actually a Belgian murder mystery in an English setting. The protagonist is René Magritte, who is at first a suspect and then becomes something of the primary investigator when the pair of local detectives summoned to investigate begin straying too far from an artist’s eye view of the evidence.
Magritte’s artwork frames the visual story in the show and is referenced, outright and subtly, throughout. He’s depicted as a quiet, sensitive young artist, far less famous than the rest of his rambunctious companions and therefore somewhat miscast in their strata of society. He doesn’t appear to really blend with the rest of the crew, but that tendency to self-alienate allows him to watch and learn while no one takes much notice of him.



“The costumes and makeup in this series are a story of their own: it was the first time I saw characters being sculpted through countless tests — the forehead of Magritte had to be smaller, Picasso’s nose bigger, the wave in Man Ray’s hair was difficult to capture. Sheila’s cut [Sheila Legge, Lord James’s niece], Lee Miller’s style, the iconic look of Lord James … all choices that evolved in the months leading up to the shoot, step by step helping to bring the characters to life.”
—Director Hans Herberts, Iconic Art in This is Not a Murder Mystery.








Yes, I know, we have a character who is a woman being addressed as “Lord,” which is never referenced by any of the characters in the show. Everyone just calls her “Lord James” and uses masculine honorifics at the same time using female pronouns for her. This bit of gender play is actually really fascinating within the context of Surrealism, and I wish there was more dialogue out there about why the writer made this decision. I’ve scoured the English internet and even tried to delve into the French and Dutch articles on the show, and it never seems to come up in the commentary. Now, Lord James was a real person, and was male/male-presenting, and he really did sponsor many of the artists depicted in this show, but beyond the name, there seems to be little else of the real person informing the character of Lord James.
(N.B.: Apparently there is a follow-up mini-show after each episode called “This is Not Fiction” that discusses the differences between the show’s plot and the lives of the real people they based the characters on. I can’t find these episodes anywhere on the American internet, so I know absolutely nothing about the topics they cover — that said, I’d love to watch these episodes because some of the questions raised by the series may actually be addressed.)
Also, we should talk a little about Lord James’ dinner jacket as well. Remember how I said that Elsa Schiaparelli’s work was referenced repeatedly? Well, this dinner jacket is by far the most direct reference we are afforded. It largely takes inspiration from Schiaparelli’s 1938 evening jacket in the collection at the Metropolitan Museum of Art:



And finally, the one major unanswered question I have, aside from really hankering for more discourse on Lord James’ character, is why on earth they chose to have DC Mary Quant share the same name as the 1960s British fashion designer Mary Quant. Seriously, it was the most distracting thing about the show. Every time they referred to DC Quant, I couldn’t stop myself from mentally becoming derailed over trying to figure out what connection, if any, there was between the fictional policewoman and the fashion designer. There appears to be no direct correlation between the two, but Quant is such a distinctive and fairly uncommon name. Is there a double meaning here??? Am I just too dense to figure it out??? Of course, none of the written material about the show mentions the name as a reference to anything. I’m not kidding, this has kept me up at least one night during the run of the show. If you know of anything that discusses the decision to name DC Quant after Mary Quant, drop it in the comments!

Did you watch This is Not a Murder Mystery (2025)? Share your thoughts in the comments!
Find this frock flick at:

YES YES YES there needs to be a Schiaparelli biopic. Given her story, it could be a full mini series like the Spanish Balenciaga biopic which I genuinely thought was superb. The lady had the most wild life, got up to so much from a young age, and even allowing for her (self-confessed) embellishments and embroideries, there’s SO MUCH there to play with. Plus it’s got all the ingredients. Rebellious child with lovely inspiring Egyptologist and astronomer uncles jumping out of windows with umbrellas and nearly choking herself with flower seeds (so that she would grow flowers from her face and look beautiful) becomes rebellious teen horrifying prudish family by publishing racy poetry becomes determined single mother abandoned by feckless conman Bad Husband raises herself and disabled child in Paris rat infested garret (with requisite adorable ratter doggo who turns out to be scared of rats), has ongoing feud with everyone’s favourite repeatedly filmed/biopicked couturier Coco (including attempted murder at one point when Coco “accidentally” sets her on fire), who knows all the artists, who goes on to mentor Givenchy and Cardin and inspire Yves Saint Laurent, and who just…. WHY hasn’t she been filmed yet? The one time we see her represented on screen, she steals the scene in aforementioned Balenciaga biopic with a great line about not kissing N*zi arse.
You could pretty much have written the outline for the biopic with this comment! Hollywood, take note!
By the sounds of things they’re reluctant to mount a biopic when it already sounds more OTT than most historical fiction!
But then again, you’d think that would be exactly why it would be such a proposition! Boring isn’t commercial – at least you’d think.
Hugely in love with 1920s/30s Surrealism! A huge YES to an Elsa Schiaparelli miniseries or biopic!
Surrealism is my happy place. I still kick myself for talking myself out of doing my graduate work on it, and instead focusing on 18th c. French portraiture, lol. I think I would have had way more fun but hindsight and all that, eh?
I’m loving the hair on everyone, and the costumes on Gala Dali, and we really need more info on the Lord James and Mary Quant conundrum.
I’ll have to see if this is available to stream here in the UK; I’m a fan of Surrealism and inter-war art in general, like Expressionism, and the stories behind it.
Update: huzzah! It’s available via Channel 4!
Watch This Is Not a Murder Mystery | Stream free on Channel 4
Year ago, I was fortunate enough to visit the Met exhibit Schiaparelli & Prada: Impossible Conversations. The exhibit compared and contrasted the works of the two designers. The impossible conversations conceit featured videos with actresses playing the two discussing their art with one another. The final video at the end of the exhibit featured the two chatting about whether they would have been friends if they’d ever met.
This is the closest thing to a frock flick I’ve seen of Schiap.
I’m sorry you don’t express more clearly your opinion on the show. I’m not liking it, mostly because like most streaming series, it’s too long with the middle episodes feeling very padded out. Also the Surrealism aspect seems to exist simply so the show can drop visual Easter eggs a couple times per episode. Like you, I find the Lord James conundrum stuff distracting and silly. I guess I’ll finish it (I have 2 more episodes to go) but I don’t love it like I wanted to.