10 thoughts on “MCM: Edward IV

  1. There is much evidence to indicate that Richard did not kill the princes in the tower. No need to as they were found to be illegitimate. Edward had never divorced his first wife so his marriage to Elizabeth was not valid.

    1. The Ricardian scholarship certainly makes that much plain and I’m sure His Late Majesty would be delighted to see you honour his vision for the history of England.

      Meanwhile the rest of us have our suspicions and will draw our own conclusions.

    2. Agreed, but I’m a member of the R3 Society, and therefore biased. Getting back to E4, Ian Hunter (minus the Brylcreem) looks like a good physical match for Edward, who was 6’3″, built and gorgeous, not to mention charming, shrewd and arguably the best warrior king England produced. (Hedonism did him in.) Max Irons is a dim frat rat by comparison.

    3. There’s a lot of evidence that he did, too, and it outweighs all the suppositions. No good evidence that he didn’t kill them has ever been discovered, so the “probably” is reasonable, since it’s more probable that he or one of his allies had them killed.

      1. Yes thank you. Of course we never can know for sure, but Richard had learned from the times he lived in that one shouldn’t leave ex-kings hanging around to become rivals. To leave the two princes alive and to let them grow up and become focal points for rebellions and insurrections would be foolish. And Richard was not a fool.

    4. When you are responsible for two kids and they go missing in a country you are currently running in a castle filled with your men, you are responsible for it even if you didn’t suffocate them yourself. Even if it was a Thomas Beckett type situation, why was the man who took the initiative punished publicly? That would have been great PR.

      Furthermore, we know now that Thomas More personally knew the sons of one of the guys who supposedly killed the boys and that the man he said ordered it’s sister in law had a necklace that belonged little Edward decades later. Thomas More was not a liar or a butt-kisser. What he said was the truth.

  2. I am deeply, deeply sad to see that – at least to date – nobody seems to have had the good sense and good taste to cast an actor who can and/or has played King Henry VIII as his lookalike grandad.

  3. The puffy-haired guy in the still from the 1962 TOWER OF LONDON was Robert Brown (best known for the late ’60s TV series HERE COME THE BRIDES) as “Sir Justin”– whoever that was.

    Justice Watson was a nondescript older man who did occasional TV bit parts; this portrayal of Edward IV was his last role. Vincent Price was playing Richard III under Roger Corman’s direction in a spooked-up film as a slight variation on their their Poe films for a rival studio.

    And that’s Vincent Price as the Duke of Clarence in the shots with Ian Hunter as Edward in the 1939 TOWER OF LONDON. Since the “club-footed executioner” in that one was Boris Karloff, both versions actually wound up on TV in “Shock Theater” packages in the 1960s.

Leave a Reply to EDCancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.