12 thoughts on “Can We Talk About Olivier’s Hamlet?

  1. I also prefer the Brannagh version and the Mel Gibson too over this one. The costumes on the Olivier are a mishmash of eras. Pseudo-Elizabethan and Medieval. The acting too is a bit much. Does Olivier chew the scenery in all his scenes or am I anti-Olivier. I don’t think I am anti-Olivier just feel that what acting wise MAY have worked in the 1940s on stage and on film does not necessarily work today. The classic films like All About Eve notwithstanding.
    It seems to me that the designer didn’t pick an era and stick to it.

      1. Same here. I probably should appreciate him, but I’ve never understood the attraction some people have to him. He is the LEAST attractive actor to me.

  2. I love the version done for The Shakespeare Plays with Derek Jacobi, Patrick Stewart, Claire Bloom, Eric Porter, and Lalla Ward. Lower budget and more of a filmed stage play, but it works on all levels.

    1. That’s my favorite one, too! I know a lot of people’s favorite is the Brannagh version, but that was a movie I loved the first time I watched it, but I didn’t think it held up well on a rewatch.

      Plus, I just like Jacobi’s line readings the best out of the 4 Hamlet versions I’ve watched.

      1. My favorite line reading of Jacobi’s is when he almost quietly says, It HATH made me mad” instead of the usual bombastic “It hath made me MAD!” It was that one line that made that Hamlet my all-time top version.

  3. I’ve never felt the love for Olivier in film. This movie especially annoys me as it is so obvious everyone else got the short end of the scenes and dialog as Olivier slashed them almost to the point of non-existence except for his part.

    I too prefer the Branagh version and as much as the Gibson interpretation has been criticized heavily, I very much enjoyed it too. Another fave is Rosencranz and Gildenstern Are Dead!

    Can’t comment much on the costumes but your captions gave me a delightful giggle!

  4. I fell in love with this film when I was in high school… (okay, I am OLD)… I am fairly ignorant on costuming but loved your captions. The hammy, heavy performances have wormed their way into my heart in spite of everything. Yeah, I love Branagh’s “unedited” version, but this one owns my heart. At the time I thought Olivier was actually blond (didn’t connect him with the guy in Wuthering Heights!) and I really had the feels for this. Made me love Shakespeare. Really.

    Just had to express a minority, very-non-hipster opinion!

  5. I’ve never felt the love for Olivier in film.

    Neither have I, if I must be brutally honest. There are a few of his roles that I truly liked. But I have never been that much of a fan of his as a screen actor. He tends to be a bit stagey at times. I read somewhere that director William Wyler literally had to teach him to hold back when acting in front of the camera. Yet, even in “Wuthering Heights”, there were still moments when he was a bit stagey. I don’t know how good Vivian Leigh was on stage, but in front of a movie camera, she was the better performer.

    As for the costumes in this movie . . . dare I say it? All over the place? I guess this film did not age very well.

  6. The Jean Simmons version of mad Ophelia with flowers in her unkempt hair was obviously the inspiration of a character on the ’60s “Addams Family” series– Morticia’s sister Ophelia Frump:



    While she usually just had the wildly matted hair, in at least one appearance she even got the “because of Denmark” braids– taken to a level anticipating Bo Derek’s cornrows in “10”:


    IIRC, Ophelia Frump had her daisies actually growing out of her head– at one point when someone tried to pull one, her knee went up and she remarked, “That one has long roots”.

  7. I adore the Kenneth Branagh version, it just feels right. David Tenant was in a modern version that I thought was very good as well.

  8. My favorite trivia concerning this “Hamlet” is about the actress playing Hamlet’s mother. Eileen Herlie, was actually 11 years younger than Olivier playing her son. The movie did nothing for her career though inspite of all its awards. That had to wait almost 30 more years when she became a TV soap star as Myrtle Fargate in “All My Children” in the ’70’s.

Comments are closed.

Discover more from Frock Flicks

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue Reading